Old Teacher Charged with Rape After School Investigation
Introduction
Matthew Rutledge is 64 years old. He was a history teacher at Miss Hall''s School. On April 16, 2025, a court charged him with three counts of rape. Two former students, Hilary Simon and Melissa Fares, said he hurt them. At first, the district attorney did not want to charge him.
Main Body
Rutledge said he was not guilty in court. He can stay out of jail but must not talk to the women. The bad things happened between 2000 and 2010. The women said Rutledge started to be too friendly when they were 14 or 15 years old. The abuse started after they turned 16. Simon said the abuse continued for years after she left the school. In 2024, the district attorney said no to charges. The law says sex with a person 16 or older is okay. The women wanted to change the law. The school paid a law firm to investigate. The firm wrote a 60-page report. It said Rutledge abused at least five students over 20 years. It also said school leaders did not stop him. The report talked about other bad workers too. After the report, the district attorney gave the case to new lawyers and police. A grand jury then decided to charge Rutledge. The women spoke about their pain. Fares said the school knew about Rutledge and helped the abuse. Simon said she waited 20 years for a call from another survivor. The school said the court date was an important and painful moment. It said it was sorry for the harm. The district attorney said the new report helped them charge Rutledge.
Conclusion
Rutledge must go to court again on June 18, 2025. This case changed because of the school''s investigation and new legal work.