First Female Archbishop of Canterbury to Meet Pope Leo XIV Despite Ongoing Doctrinal Disagreements
Introduction
Archbishop Sarah Mullally, the first woman to lead the Anglican Communion, is scheduled to meet Pope Leo XIV in Rome for a four-day visit starting April 25. This will be the first high-level meeting between the two churches since 1966, when Archbishop Michael Ramsey met Pope Paul VI. The meeting takes place amid persistent disagreements over the ordination of women and other social issues.
Main Body
The upcoming meeting follows six decades of gradual improvement in relations between the Church of England and the Roman Catholic Church, which separated in the 16th century. However, a joint statement in 2016 acknowledged 'new disagreements,' especially regarding women's ordination. Mullally's appointment as the first female leader of the global Anglican community—about 85 million members—represents a major change in church governance. This contrasts sharply with Catholic doctrine, which does not allow women to serve as priests or deacons. The Catholic Church maintains an all-male clergy, although the late Pope Francis appointed women to senior administrative roles, such as Sister Simona Brambilla as prefect of a Vatican department and Sister Raffaella Petrini as president of the Vatican City governorate. In 2023, women were allowed to vote in the Synod for the first time. However, a Vatican commission in December 2025 decided not to recommend allowing women deacons, and Pope Leo XIV has stated he will not change core doctrine on this matter. In contrast, the Church of England approved female priests in 1992 and female bishops in 2014. Currently, 37% of its active clergy are women, and 36 female bishops serve, with 12 leading dioceses. The majority of those training for ordained ministry are women. Both churches face similar pressures, including scandals of clerical child sexual abuse. Mullally's predecessor, Justin Welby, resigned over failures in handling such cases. There are also internal divisions between conservative and progressive groups on issues like liturgy, same-sex marriage, and priestly celibacy. Mullally's own appointment drew criticism from several conservative African archbishops because of her gender and her supportive stance on same-sex marriage. Pope Leo inherited a similarly divided Catholic Church from Pope Francis, whose reform efforts often upset traditionalists. Women's rights campaigners, such as Sylvaine Landrivon of the Catholic feminist association Magdala, expressed hope that Mullally's visit might lead the Catholic Church to reconsider women's roles. Bishop Anthony Ball, the archbishop's representative to the Holy See, described the meeting as a chance to build a personal relationship and to address shared challenges including immigration, poverty, war, and environmental issues. Ball stated that he expects Pope Leo to be respectful of Mullally's position and that she will not raise the issue of women's ordination within the Catholic Church, as she is focused on internal Anglican matters. He characterized both leaders as 'quite careful listeners' who are taking time to decide on future steps.
Conclusion
The meeting between Archbishop Mullally and Pope Leo XIV highlights both the progress and the ongoing divisions in Christian ecumenical relations. Although the two leaders share common ground on social issues and a desire for unity, fundamental doctrinal differences—especially regarding gender and church authority—remain unresolved.